October Natural Gas is down 4.4 cents at $2.465 this morning as I write. This is right on the up trend line coming up from the lows made in 1991, just after this futures contract came into existence. I remember over the past year where members of Congress have blamed speculators for the run up in petroleum prices, which is totally not true. Speculators and hedgers as well may have accelerated the move in the petroleum products, but they weren’t the cause. I believe that you still have to look at China and India, for starters. Their demand for energy has ramped up considerably over the last few years. Congress can’t mess with them, so they have to try to find a culprit and speculators are the easy target. This is like a small town murder, and the police are under severe pressure to arrest someone, so they grab the first person off the street that looks suspicious and arrests him, whether or not he is guilty. In the mean time the real culprit is loose.
Recently Congress has put enough pressure on the CFTC to limit the ability of ETN’s (Exchange Traded Notes), and ETF’s (Exchange Traded Funds), to acquire more futures contracts on Natural Gas, inhibiting their ability to mirror the movement in the underlying commodity, in this case, natural gas. So some ETN’s have chosen to close down. I am note sure about any ETF’s. I believe this is causing those entities to have to liquidate gas contracts as they shut down. The general public invested in these things are now getting hurt as they liquidate their ETN’s. WHO IS MANIPULATING THE MARKET NOW? Congress!!
I believe that free markets will always correct themselves. Changes in supply and demand evolve over time and eventually prices reach high enough levels where buyers finally can’t stand it anymore so the market will fall back in price. On the other hand, when prices get low enough, then many producers in this case will be driven out of business and may not be back any time soon. The eventual result will be supply dropping too low and then prices will rise again. The unintended consequence caused by Congressional manipulators, will be the prices will actually go higher and stay higher because it may take time to get new procucers to get back in the business or get bank credit. So next time natural gas prices hit $15, the cause will be Congress not letting free markets determine the price. This is very sad to watch.
We can look at other times in history where the government interfered with the free markets, and EVERY time there were negative consequences. If I owned an ETF in natural gas, I would hold on for the long run. For the long run, this period could be the best time to accumulate natural gas for the next time prices spike up again, which they eventually will. For now, we are awash in supply. For now we will stand aside until we get a valid buy signal.
Sep. 4, 2009
David Hall
Continue Reading